This piece in the Village Voice struck me as a waste of ink and bytes. Jerry Saltz ponders and complains about the social circles that make up the art world. He takes a particular shot at the Diary section of artforum.com, calling it the US magazine of art criticism. I suppose the slam of artforum.com was new, but the critique and the lament are nothing new at all. There's always been a junior high angle to art crtitics, there always will be. When you get down to it, any endeavor that relies on criticism (or some form of it) where the standards used to judge it are rather subjective is going to run into the you-can't-sit-at-my-lunchtable problem. It's pretty much woven into the fabric of what the art world is.
He is right, though. That Diary section is a glorified version of this site. I think it's funny that the two sites can cover the same event. Tells you all you need to know about the "Scene".